Drawing of Caelle, Vae, and Isaac dressed up as characters from Dungeon Meshi. Caelle is dressed as Senshi, Vae is dressed as Laios, and Isaac is dressed as Marcille.
Diagram showing how I decided which character should be who. My characters and their corresponding Dungeon Meshi character are paired off into columns, and beneath each pair is a bulleted list of similarities the characters share. A list of attributes for both Isaac and Marcille reads: 'Anxious, Healer, Feels like a burden, Often having a terrible time, Failgirl swag'. A list of attributes for both Caelle and Senshi reads: 'Easygoing, Excellent cook, Will protect you, Sexy'. A list of attributes for Vae and Laios reads: 'Weird quiet guy, Very specialized knowledge, Unusual interests, Big neutral face emoji energy'.

Dungeon Meshi

I drew this around the time I started reading Dungeon Meshi for the first time. I tried to pick who was who based on personality, matching my characters' personalities to whichever Dungeon Meshi character was closest. Since I wasn't very far into Dungeon Meshi at the time (I think I was only on chapter 4 or 5), my reads on the characters were a little shaky, and, in some cases, there were also other, more fitting characters who I hadn't met yet.

I later decided that Vae is maybe a little bit more of an Izutsumi, for example.

Anyway, you should read Dungeon Meshi.